SIAC, which commenced operations in 1991 as an independent, not-for-profit organisation, has a proven track record in providing quality, neutral arbitration services to the global business community.

  • Welcome to SIAC
next
prev
Loading…

Highlights

SIAC-KAA Seoul ADR Festival Seminar


7 November 2018
SIAC-KAA Seoul ADR Festival Seminar

By Philip Kim, Senior Associate, Herbert Smith Freehills

The Seoul ADR Festival Seminar, hosted by SIAC and the Korean Arbitrators Association (KAA) on 7 November 2018, was an opportunity for practitioners to join "A Conversation with International Arbitral Institutions". Insights were shared on a range of topics including the appointment of arbitrators and the inner workings of international arbitral institutions. A consistent theme was the importance of cooperation between institutions, to create a larger "mooncake" that all those in the international arbitration field can share. The seminar was well-attended by practitioners, in-house counsel and academics.

The opening address was delivered by Mr Ki-Su Lee (Chairman and CEO, KAA), where he welcomed practitioners, academics, a former judge and former presidents of the KAA to the conference.

In the first session, Mr Michael Lee (Vice President, International Centre for Dispute Resolution (ICDR), American Arbitration Association (AAA)) shared his insights on how to build a career as an international arbitrator. Mr Lee noted the lack of a requisite exam or qualification to "become" an arbitrator, and that an arbitrator’s career often begins by being a party-appointed arbitrator before joining the panel of an arbitral institution. Mr Lee emphasised the central importance of building one’s reputation and credibility as an arbitrator.

Mr Xu Wei (Deputy Secretary General, China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission (CIETAC)) then gave his observations on the growth of arbitration in China. In 2017, for example, CIETAC accepted 2,298 arbitration cases and also launched the Public-Private Partnership Arbitration Centre. Mr Xu also expressed a desire for more collaboration between CIETAC and Korean arbitral institutions.

In the next session, Mr Chan Leng Sun, SC (Deputy Chairman, Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC); Senior Counsel and Arbitrator, Essex Court Chambers Duxton) considered the special features of maritime arbitration in Singapore and London, highlighting the different practices, rules and culture of the arbitral institutions that specialise in maritime disputes. For example, the use of "umpires" is a unique feature of maritime arbitration, and the London Maritime Arbitration Association does not administer the arbitration and instead adopts a very "light touch" approach. In addition to providing a practitioner's insight into maritime arbitration, Mr Chan's presentation pointed to the potential of maritime arbitration as a source of inspiration for improvement of procedures in commercial arbitrations. It will be interesting to see if cross fertilisation of ideas for improvement would lead to the adoption of "umpires" and other unique features of maritime arbitration in general commercial arbitration.

P1080307 P1080284
Members of the audience

Group photo with speakers and delegates

The final session was a lively discussion moderated by Dr Hongseok Aaron Kim (Vice Chairman, KAA) with the panel comprising Mr Chan, Mr Chen Zhao Hui (Deputy Secretary General, CIETAC Fujian Sub-Commission), Mr Kevin Nash (Deputy Registrar and Centre Director, SIAC), Mr Lee and Mr Xu.

The panel first delved into the question of how to be appointed as an arbitrator and the essential qualities, experience or skills that an arbitrator requires. Mr Lee and Mr Chen emphasised the distinction between being listed on an institutional panel and actually being appointed in a particular case. A particular focus was on the need to gain experience as an arbitrator, which Mr Nash described as a 'chicken and egg' situation that faces younger arbitrators seeking out their first appointment.

The panellists then shared their perspectives on the issue of arbitrator fees, which are often calculated either on the basis of an hourly rate or a percentage of the sum in dispute. Mr Lee acknowledged the difficulties here with his answer that "it depends". Mr Chan emphasised the connection with the complexity of the case as well as the skills and experience of the arbitrator – but noted that typically younger arbitrators would be willing to take on smaller value cases to gain the necessary experience. Mr Nash discussed the ICC Commission report indicating the usual spread of fees in a typical arbitration being 83% in counsel fees, 15% in arbitrator fees and 2% in the institution's administrative fees – and that generally counsel and the arbitrator are happy where the ratio is approximately 5:1.

In discussing the scenario where a party refuses to pay its share of the arbitrator fees (particularly in the context where there is increasing use of contingency fees and third party funding), the panel agreed with Mr Chen's comments about the importance of obtaining appropriate and timely deposits from the parties.

The discussion then turned to what each arbitral institution was doing to support the Korean community in the field of international arbitration. Mr Nash noted the growth of SIAC in Korea, and that Korean parties have constantly been within the top ten foreign users of SIAC, with Korean arbitrators being the seventh most frequently appointed at SIAC. Mr Nash also mentioned the efforts of Ms Seah Lee (Head (North East Asia), SIAC) and the importance of her role in the Korean market. Mr Chen added that there are many similarities between China and Korea, and asked whether Koreans are familiar with Chinese mooncakes. He used the analogy that all those working in arbitration are dividing up a mooncake to share – and that we should be trying to make a bigger mooncake through cooperation among arbitral institutions. In doing so, everyone can get a bigger share. What was implied in these discussions was that this cooperation would lead to better procedures that are more just and efficient, thereby making international arbitration more attractive for its users, compared to other forms of dispute resolution.

The closing remarks of Mr Chan returned to this theme of cooperation and collaboration between arbitral institutions in order to improve the arbitral process and serve the business community. This echoed his earlier remarks about the fact there is a real dialogue occurring between arbitral institutions which has led to some harmonisation of practices and the creation of consistent experiences for end users. The final message was that arbitral institutions should work together to make a "better, bigger and more delicious mooncake".

Press Releases

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9

SIAC Announces the Official Release of the SIAC Rules 2016

30 June 2016SIAC Announces the Official Release of the SIAC Rules 2016The Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) is pleased to announce the official release of the sixth edition of the Arbitration Rules of the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (“SIAC Rules 2016”). The SIAC Rules 2016 will be available on the SIAC website from 1 July 2016, and will come into e...

Read more

SIAC Signs Memorandum of Agreement with GIFT

3 June 2016SIAC Signs Memorandum of Agreement with GIFT The Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) is pleased to announce that it has entered into a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with the Gujarat International Finance Tec-City Company Limited (GIFTCL) and GIFT SEZ Limited (GIFT SEZ). Under the MOA, SIAC, GIFTCL and GIFT SEZ will collaborate to promote the use of arbit...

Read more

SIAC Announces Appointment of New Registrar and Promotion of Deputy Registrar

27 April 2016SIAC Announces Appointment of New Registrar and Promotion of Deputy RegistrarThe Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) is pleased to announce the appointment of Ms Delphine Ho as Registrar of SIAC with effect from 20 May 2016, and the promotion of its Deputy Registrar, Mr Kevin Nash, to Deputy Registrar and Centre Director, effective 1 May 2016. Ms Ho wi...

Read more

SIAC Signs Memorandum of Understanding with Oe-Cusse Administration

28 March 2016SIAC Signs Memorandum of Understanding with Oe-Cusse AdministrationThe Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) is pleased to announce that it has entered into a Memorandum of Understanding with the Authority of the Special Administrative Region of Oe-Cusse Ambeno (SAROA) and Special Zones for Social Market Economy (ZEESM) Timor-Leste (SAROA-ZEESM TL), form...

Read more

SIAC Announces Record Case Numbers for 2015

25 February 2016SIAC Announces Record Case Numbers for 2015 The Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) is pleased to announce the official release of its 2015 Annual Report at the SIAC Annual Appreciation Event this evening. 2015 was a milestone year for SIAC. SIAC recorded the highest ever number of cases filed, highest ever number of administered cases and highest e...

Read more

Public Consultation on Draft SIAC Investment Arbitration Rules

1 February 2016Public Consultation on Draft SIAC Investment Arbitration RulesThe Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) is pleased to announce the commencement of the public consultation process on its draft Investment Arbitration Rules 2016 (the “draft IA Rules”), a comprehensive set of specialised rules for the administration of investment arbitrations by SIAC.The d...

Read more

SIAC Appoints New Court Member

1 February 2016SIAC Appoints New Court MemberThe Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) is pleased to announce the appointment of Mr Darius Khambata, Senior Counsel, to the SIAC Court of Arbitration with effect from 1 February 2016.Mr Khambata practises before the Bombay High Court and the Supreme Court of India. He has previously held two distinguished public law off...

Read more

Opening of SIAC Office in Shanghai

25 January 2016Opening of SIAC Office in ShanghaiThe Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) is pleased to announce the opening of a representative office in the China (Shanghai) Pilot Free Trade Zone (FTZ). The launch of the Shanghai office underpins SIAC’s steadily growing popularity amongst Chinese parties, and is an integral part of SIAC’s continuous efforts to for...

Read more

Public Consultation on Draft SIAC Arbitration Rules

18 January 2016Public Consultation on Draft SIAC Arbitration RulesThe Singapore International Arbitration Centre (“SIAC”) is pleased to announce the opening of the public consultation process on its draft revised Arbitration Rules 2016 (the “draft Rules”). The revision of SIAC’s Arbitration Rules takes into account recent developments in international arbitration practice and pr...

Read more
You are here: Home SIAC News SIAC-KAA Seoul ADR Festival Seminar